Can Different Shareholders Receive Different Dividends?

Yes, different shareholders in a UK limited company can receive different dividend amounts. However, the payments must follow the rights attached to their shares and the company must have sufficient distributable profits.

A company cannot simply choose to pay shareholders differently when they own identical shares with equal dividend rights.

Why might shareholders receive different amounts?

Shareholders may receive different dividends because they:

• Own different numbers of shares
• Hold different classes of shares
• Have different dividend rights
• Hold preference or alphabet shares
• Have validly waived their entitlement to a dividend

For example, a shareholder who owns 70 ordinary shares will normally receive more than someone who owns 30 shares of the same class.

Can shareholders with the same share class receive different dividends?

Shareholders holding the same class of shares should normally receive the same dividend per share.

If two shareholders each hold 50 ordinary shares with identical rights, paying one shareholder more per share than the other could breach the company’s Articles or the rights attached to those shares.

The company may need separate share classes or a properly executed dividend waiver to create a lawful difference.

How do alphabet shares allow different dividends?

Alphabet shares divide ordinary shares into separate classes, commonly described as A shares, B shares and C shares.

Each class can have its own dividend rights. Subject to the Articles and share terms, the company may declare:

• A dividend on A shares only
• A different dividend rate for B shares
• No dividend on another class
• Separate dividends at different times

This structure is often used where founders, investors or family members require different income arrangements.

What is a dividend waiver?

A dividend waiver allows a shareholder to give up their right to receive a particular dividend.

The waiver should normally:

• Be made before the dividend becomes payable
• Be documented clearly
• Identify the shares and dividend covered
• Be properly signed, preferably as a deed
• Have a genuine commercial or personal purpose

Dividend waivers can create legal and tax complications, particularly when used repeatedly or mainly to redirect income to another shareholder. Professional advice is recommended.

Can directors decide who receives a dividend?

Directors can approve interim dividends, but they must follow the rights attached to each share class.

They cannot ignore those rights or select individual shareholders from the same class simply because they want to pay them different amounts.

If flexible dividends are required, the company may need to create separate share classes and amend its Articles before making the payment.

Must the company have enough profit?

Yes. Different dividend arrangements do not change the requirement for distributable profits.

Before approving a dividend, directors should confirm that:

• The company has sufficient available profits
• The payment will not make the company insolvent
• The Articles permit the dividend
• The relevant share-class rights are followed
• The decision is properly recorded

Having enough cash in the bank does not automatically mean a dividend can legally be paid.

What records should be kept?

The company should keep:

• Board minutes
• Any shareholder resolution required
• Evidence of distributable profits
• Dividend vouchers
• Share-class records
• Any dividend waiver
• Proof of payment

Each dividend voucher should show the company name, shareholder’s name, payment date and dividend amount.

Are there tax risks?

Potentially. Dividend arrangements involving spouses, family members, employees or connected parties may attract additional scrutiny if they appear designed mainly to redirect income or avoid tax.

Dividends should reflect genuine share ownership and valid share rights. Payments that are effectively rewards for employment may also be treated differently for tax purposes.

What happens if the dividend is paid incorrectly?

An incorrectly paid dividend may be treated as unlawful.

A shareholder may have to repay it if they knew, or had reasonable grounds to believe, that the distribution was improper. Directors may also face consequences for approving a payment without sufficient profits or proper authority.

Final answer

Different UK shareholders can receive different dividends when they own different numbers or classes of shares, have different dividend rights or use a valid dividend waiver.

Shareholders holding identical shares within the same class should normally receive the same dividend per share. The company should check its Articles, share rights and available profits before approving unequal payments.

This article provides general information and does not constitute legal, tax or financial advice.

‍