Shares in a UK limited company are usually valued by considering the company’s financial performance, assets, liabilities, future prospects and the rights attached to the shares.

There is no single compulsory valuation method for most private company share sales. The final price is normally negotiated between the buyer and seller, subject to the company’s articles of association and any shareholders’ agreement.

Is the Share Value the Same as Its Nominal Value?

No. The nominal value of a share is not normally its sale value.

A company may issue shares with a nominal value of £1 each, but those shares could later be worth considerably more or less. Nominal value is mainly an accounting and legal figure representing part of the company’s share capital.

The market value is the amount the shares might reasonably sell for between a willing buyer and seller.

How Is the Value of a Company Calculated?

Before valuing an individual shareholding, the parties usually estimate the value of the entire company.

The calculation may consider:

  • Annual revenue
  • Profit and cash flow
  • Company assets
  • Outstanding debts and liabilities
  • Customer relationships
  • Contracts and recurring income
  • Intellectual property
  • Brand reputation
  • Market position
  • Growth prospects
  • Risks facing the business

Once the overall company value has been estimated, the value of the shares being sold can be considered.

Common Methods for Valuing UK Company Shares

Several methods may be used, depending on the type and stage of the business.

Earnings Multiple Method

This method values the company by applying a multiple to its maintainable earnings or operating profit.

For example, if a company generates adjusted annual earnings of £200,000 and an appropriate multiple is four, its estimated enterprise value could be £800,000.

The calculation may then be adjusted for company cash, debt and other liabilities.

The appropriate multiple depends on factors such as the industry, growth rate, business risks and recent transactions involving comparable companies.

Asset-Based Valuation

An asset-based valuation considers the value of the company’s assets after deducting its liabilities.

Assets may include:

  • Cash
  • Property
  • Stock
  • Equipment
  • Investments
  • Intellectual property
  • Money owed by customers

This approach may be suitable for property, investment or asset-heavy companies. It may be less useful for service companies whose value depends mainly on employees, contracts or future earnings.

Discounted Cash-Flow Valuation

A discounted cash-flow valuation estimates the company’s future cash flows and converts them into a present value.

This method can be useful for established businesses with predictable financial performance. However, it depends heavily on assumptions about future growth, costs and risk.

Dividend-Based Valuation

A dividend-based approach considers the income shareholders can reasonably expect to receive from the shares.

It may be relevant where a company has a stable and established dividend history. It may be less suitable for growing companies that reinvest most of their profits.

Comparable Transaction Method

This approach compares the company with similar businesses or shareholdings that have recently been sold.

Finding reliable comparisons can be difficult for small private companies because their sale prices and financial information are not always publicly available.

How Is the Value Per Share Calculated?

A simple starting point is to divide the company’s equity value by the total number of issued shares.

For example, if the company’s equity value is £500,000 and it has issued 1,000 identical ordinary shares, the starting value could be £500 per share.

However, this calculation may need to be adjusted because not all shares carry identical rights or represent the same level of control.

Does the Size of the Shareholding Affect Its Value?

Yes. A controlling shareholding may be worth more per share than a small minority interest.

A buyer may pay a control premium for shares that provide the ability to:

  • Appoint or remove directors
  • Control shareholder decisions
  • Approve major transactions
  • Influence the company’s dividend policy
  • Change the articles of association
  • Sell or restructure the business

A minority shareholding may be valued at a discount because its owner has limited control and may find it difficult to sell the shares to another buyer.

A 10% shareholding is therefore not always worth exactly 10% of the company’s total value.

Do Different Share Classes Have Different Values?

Yes. Different classes of shares may carry different:

  • Voting rights
  • Dividend rights
  • Rights to company capital
  • Redemption rights
  • Conversion rights
  • Rights when the company is sold or wound up

Preference shares may have priority over ordinary shares for dividends or the return of capital. Non-voting shares may be less attractive to some buyers, while shares carrying enhanced voting rights may have a higher value.

The articles and share terms should be examined carefully before determining the value.

Do the Articles Affect the Sale Price?

The company’s articles of association and shareholders’ agreement may contain rules that affect the value and sale of shares.

These may include:

  • Rights of first refusal for existing shareholders
  • Pre-emption rights
  • A compulsory valuation formula
  • Restrictions on selling to an outside buyer
  • Director approval requirements
  • Good-leaver and bad-leaver provisions
  • Drag-along and tag-along rights
  • Compulsory transfer provisions

Some agreements require an independent accountant or valuation expert to determine “fair value” or “market value.” These terms can produce different results depending on how they are defined.

Can the Buyer and Seller Agree Any Price?

In an ordinary commercial transaction, the buyer and seller can generally negotiate their own price.

However, selling shares for less than market value may have tax consequences, particularly when the buyer and seller are connected. HMRC may use the shares’ market value instead of the actual sale price when calculating the seller’s taxable gain in certain circumstances.

This can apply when shares are sold or given to relatives, business partners or connected companies.

Should the Company’s Debt Be Deducted?

Usually, yes. Many valuations begin with an enterprise value and then adjust for the company’s debt and available cash to calculate its equity value.

Other adjustments may be made for:

  • Surplus cash
  • Outstanding loans
  • Unpaid tax
  • Directors’ loan accounts
  • Unusual liabilities
  • Insufficient working capital
  • One-off income or expenses

The share purchase agreement should clearly state whether the price is based on a debt-free, cash-free or another agreed basis.

What Financial Information Will a Buyer Review?

A buyer may conduct due diligence before agreeing to the share price.

This may include reviewing:

  • Annual accounts
  • Management accounts
  • Tax returns
  • Business bank statements
  • Customer and supplier contracts
  • Payroll records
  • Loans and financial commitments
  • Intellectual property ownership
  • Legal claims
  • Company registers
  • Share certificates and share rights

Problems discovered during due diligence may reduce the price or result in additional protections being included in the sale agreement.

Is Capital Gains Tax Payable?

A shareholder may have to pay Capital Gains Tax when selling shares for more than their allowable cost.

The taxable gain is generally based on the difference between the disposal value and the amount paid for the shares, after deducting eligible costs and applying any available reliefs. UK guidance explains how gains on share sales are calculated.

Some shareholders selling shares in a qualifying trading company may be eligible for Business Asset Disposal Relief. The eligibility conditions and tax rules should be checked at the time of the sale.

Is Stamp Duty Payable?

The buyer may have to pay Stamp Duty when purchasing existing shares in a UK company through a stock transfer form.

Stamp Duty is generally calculated using the consideration paid for the shares. At present, it normally applies at 0.5% where the chargeable consideration exceeds £1,000, subject to exemptions and reliefs. Current Stamp Duty guidance is available on GOV.UK.

The transaction documents and payment usually need to be submitted within the applicable deadline.

Should an Independent Valuation Be Obtained?

An independent valuation can be useful where:

  • A large shareholding is being sold
  • The buyer and seller are connected
  • A minority shareholder is leaving
  • The shareholders disagree about value
  • The articles require an independent valuation
  • Shares are being transferred to an employee or family member
  • Tax relief is being claimed
  • The company has complex assets or multiple share classes

A suitably experienced accountant, corporate finance adviser or independent valuation specialist can provide a written valuation.

Final Thoughts

UK company shares are valued by examining the company’s earnings, assets, debts, cash flow, risks and growth prospects. The shareholding’s size, voting power and dividend rights can also significantly affect its value.

The final sale price is usually negotiated, but the company’s articles, shareholders’ agreement and tax rules must be considered. For significant or connected-party transactions, obtaining an independent professional valuation can reduce the risk of disputes and unexpected tax liabilities.

‍

‍
UKcompany.blog assumes no responsibility or liability for any errors or omissions in the content of this website or blog. The information contained in this website or blog is provided on an "as is" basis with no guarantees of completeness, accuracy, usefulness, or timeliness.